(对我来说)一部彻头彻尾的大闷片一直觉得试图用镜头捕捉真实就是个伪命题因为我们所有人能做到的只是表演真实或者说真实本身就是一种流动但结尾把主创观后感收录在内这种方式来提醒观者这场“表演”来provoke思考这种形式我很受用另外很喜欢中产知识分子的回答“I believe in life. I believe in the possibility of fulfillment”. 我希望等我需要回答这个问题时仍能做好一种充分的自我保存
Compared to other works I've seen so far, this one is less in the realm of magical and suspense, equipped with much fewer whimsical and enchanting moments in the traditional sense...there is clear imbalance among these protagonists, with Ida being the one with (significantly) least screen time, but Rivette likely doesn't care. The eventual encounter of the other 2, Louise and Ninon, and the bonding thereafter, is clearly reminiscent of Celine and Julie Go Boating, and that includes their joint effort in subverting gender dynamics...see full review at https://letterboxd.com/ziggyzaggy/film/up-down-fragile/